Publication Ethics
Journal of Sharia and Local Traditions (JSLT) is a peer-reviewed, open-access journal committed to maintaining high standards of publication ethics and academic integrity. JSLT follows the principles and guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) in addressing ethical issues, research integrity, and cases of publication misconduct. This statement outlines the ethical responsibilities and expected conduct of authors, editors, reviewers, and other parties involved in the publication process. JSLT is committed to ensuring that all manuscripts are handled fairly, transparently, and confidentially. The journal does not tolerate plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, inappropriate authorship, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or any other form of unethical academic conduct. The editorial team is responsible for taking appropriate action when ethical concerns arise, including requesting clarification, correction, retraction, or other measures where necessary.
Publication Decisions
The Editor-in-Chief and editorial team are responsible for making decisions regarding the publication of manuscripts submitted to JSLT. Editorial decisions are based on the manuscript’s scholarly quality, originality, relevance to the journal’s scope, methodological or legal rigor, significance, and the recommendations of peer reviewers. Editors may consult reviewers, members of the editorial board, or other qualified experts when making publication decisions. Editorial decisions must not be influenced by the authors’ nationality, institutional affiliation, gender, religious or political background, or other personal characteristics
Confidentiality
Editors and editorial staff must maintain the confidentiality of all submitted manuscripts and related information. Manuscripts must not be disclosed to anyone other than the corresponding author, reviewers, potential reviewers, editorial advisers, and other authorized persons involved in the editorial process. Unpublished information contained in a manuscript must not be used for the editors’ own research or personal advantage without the explicit written permission of the author.
Disclosure and Conflicts of Interest
Editors and reviewers must disclose any potential conflict of interest that could affect their objectivity in handling or evaluating a manuscript. Conflicts may arise from professional, personal, academic, financial, competitive, collaborative, or institutional relationships. Individuals with a significant conflict of interest should withdraw from the editorial or review process.
Duties of Reviewers
Contribution to Editorial Decisions: Peer review assists the editors in evaluating the quality, originality, relevance, and scholarly contribution of submitted manuscripts. Reviewers’ comments should also help authors improve the clarity, rigor, and overall quality of their work.
Promptness: Reviewers who are unable to review a manuscript because of insufficient expertise, a potential conflict of interest, or other circumstances that may prevent timely completion should promptly inform the editor and decline the invitation.
Standards of Objectivity: Reviews should be conducted objectively, constructively, and respectfully. Reviewers should provide clear comments supported by appropriate scholarly reasoning or evidence. Personal criticism of authors is inappropriate and should not form part of the review.
Acknowledgement of Sources: Reviewers should identify relevant published work that has not been adequately cited by the authors. They should also inform the editor of substantial similarities, possible plagiarism, or significant overlap between the manuscript under review and other published works of which they have reliable knowledge.
Disclosure and Conflict of Interest: Information, data, arguments, or ideas obtained through peer review must remain confidential and must not be used for personal or professional advantage. Reviewers should decline to review manuscripts where their relationship with the authors, institutions, or related organizations could compromise the impartiality of their evaluation.
Review Process
JSLT applies an independent double-blind peer-review process. Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial screening are sent to qualified reviewers whose expertise is relevant to the subject of the manuscript. Reviewer identities and author identities are concealed during the review process. Manuscripts are normally evaluated by at least two reviewers. Where necessary, the editor may seek an additional review to support an appropriate editorial decision. Publication decisions may include acceptance, revision, or rejection and are based on the overall scholarly assessment of the manuscript and the editorial evaluation
Duties of Authors
Reporting Standards: Authors must present their research accurately, clearly, and objectively. The manuscript should provide sufficient methodological and contextual information to allow readers to understand how the research was conducted and how the conclusions were reached. Data, legal materials, sources, findings, and interpretations must be presented honestly. Fabricated, falsified, or knowingly inaccurate information constitutes unethical behaviour and is unacceptable.
Originality and Plagiarism: Authors must ensure that their submissions are original and have not been published previously. Any ideas, arguments, data, words, or materials derived from other sources must be appropriately acknowledged and cited. Plagiarism in any form, including substantial unattributed copying, inappropriate paraphrasing, or presenting another person’s work as one’s own, is not acceptable.
Multiple, Redundant, or Concurrent Publication: Authors should not submit the same manuscript to more than one journal simultaneously. A manuscript that substantially overlaps with previously published or submitted work must be appropriately disclosed to the editor. Duplicate or redundant publication is considered unethical publishing practice.
Acknowledgement of Sources: Authors must properly acknowledge all sources that have contributed to the development of their research. Relevant publications, legal materials, theories, data, and other scholarly contributions should be appropriately cited. Citations should accurately represent the sources being cited.
Authorship of the Paper: Authorship should be limited to individuals who have made substantial contributions to the conception, design, conduct, analysis, interpretation, or development of the manuscript. All individuals who have made significant scholarly contributions should be appropriately recognized as authors, while individuals who have contributed in a limited or non-authorial capacity should be acknowledged where appropriate. The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that all legitimate co-authors are included, that no inappropriate authors are listed, and that all authors have reviewed and approved the final version of the manuscript and agreed to its submission.
Disclosure and Conflicts of Interest: Authors must disclose any financial, professional, personal, institutional, or other substantive interests that could reasonably be perceived as influencing the research or its interpretation. All relevant sources of financial or institutional support for the research should also be disclosed.
Ethical Use of Research Materials: Authors are responsible for ensuring that the research complies with applicable ethical standards and legal requirements. Where research involves human participants, personal data, interviews, or other ethically sensitive materials, authors should obtain the necessary ethical approval or informed consent where applicable and report this appropriately in the manuscript.
Fundamental Errors in Published Works: If an author discovers a significant error or inaccuracy in a published article, the author should promptly notify the Editor-in-Chief or editorial team. The author is expected to cooperate with the journal in investigating the issue and, where necessary, correcting or retracting the published work.
Corrections and Retractions: JSLT is committed to maintaining the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record. When a published article contains a significant error, the journal may publish an appropriate correction or other editorial notice. Articles may be retracted when there is clear evidence of serious research or publication misconduct, substantial errors that invalidate the findings, plagiarism, duplicate publication, or other circumstances that seriously compromise the integrity of the scholarly record. Any correction or retraction will be handled transparently and in accordance with established publication-ethics principles.
Editorial Independence: The editorial team is responsible for maintaining the academic and editorial integrity of JSLT. Editorial decisions are made independently on the basis of scholarly and ethical considerations. External parties must not improperly influence editorial decisions, peer-review outcomes, or the content of published articles
Publication and Ethical Guidelines
The JSLT is committed to maintaining high standards of academic integrity, transparency, and responsible publishing. The following guidelines outline the responsibilities and expectations of authors, reviewers, and editors throughout the publication process. All parties are expected to act professionally, maintain academic integrity, respect confidentiality, and contribute to a fair and transparent peer-review process. These principles apply from manuscript submission through review, revision, publication, and post-publication correction
A: Publication and Authorship
| ▪ | All submitted manuscripts are subject to a strict peer-review process conducted by at least two reviewers who are experts in the relevant field. |
| ▪ | The review process applies a blind peer-review system. |
| ▪ | The review process considers relevance, originality, significance, clarity, readability, language, and scientific contribution. |
| ▪ | Editorial decisions may include acceptance, acceptance with revisions, or rejection. |
| ▪ | Authors who are requested to revise and resubmit their manuscripts are not guaranteed acceptance after revision. |
| ▪ | Rejected manuscripts will not be reviewed again. |
| ▪ | Acceptance of a manuscript is subject to legal requirements concerning defamation, copyright infringement, and plagiarism. |
| ▪ | Manuscripts must not be published or submitted simultaneously to another publication. |
B: Authors’ Responsibilities
| ▪ | Authors must ensure that their manuscripts are original works. |
| ▪ | Authors must confirm that the manuscript has not been published previously. |
| ▪ | Authors must confirm that the manuscript is not under consideration by another journal or publisher. |
| ▪ | Authors must participate actively in the peer-review process. |
| ▪ | Authors are responsible for correcting or retracting significant errors in published works. |
| ▪ | All authors listed in the manuscript must have significantly contributed to the research. |
| ▪ | Authors must ensure that all data presented are accurate, authentic, and valid. |
| ▪ | Authors must disclose any potential conflicts of interest. |
| ▪ | Authors must properly acknowledge all sources cited in the manuscript. |
| ▪ | Authors must promptly inform the editors if errors are discovered in their published work. |
C: Reviewers’ Responsibilities
| ▪ | Reviewers must maintain the confidentiality of all manuscripts under review. |
| ▪ | Reviews should be conducted objectively without personal criticism of the authors. |
| ▪ | Reviewers should provide clear comments supported by constructive arguments. |
| ▪ | Reviewers should identify relevant published works not cited by the authors. |
| ▪ | Reviewers should inform the Editor-in-Chief of any substantial similarity between the manuscript under review and other published works known to them. |
| ▪ | Reviewers must not review manuscripts where conflicts of interest exist due to personal, institutional, or professional relationships with the authors or related institutions. |
D: Editors’ Responsibilities
| ▪ | Editors have full authority and responsibility to accept or reject manuscripts. |
| ▪ | Editors are responsible for maintaining the quality and integrity of the journal publication. |
| ▪ | Editors should consider the needs of authors and readers in improving publication quality. |
| ▪ | Editors should ensure the integrity of the academic record. |
| ▪ | Editors should publish corrections or retractions when necessary. |
| ▪ | Editors should consider research funding sources in the evaluation process. |
| ▪ | Editorial decisions must be based solely on academic merit, originality, clarity, and relevance to the journal’s scope. |
| ▪ | Editors must preserve reviewer anonymity. |
| ▪ | Editors should ensure that all published research complies with internationally accepted ethical standards. |
| ▪ | Editors should take appropriate action in cases of suspected misconduct, whether before or after publication. |
| ▪ | Editors must avoid conflicts of interest involving authors, reviewers, editorial board members, or publishing staff. |